The Art of Twists and Turns

Today, many of us have the feeling of needing to escape. Escape from the future, from the past, from the inexorable complexities of the present. Many have the feeling of being pursued by hidden forces, entangled in unseen snares, ensnarled in unknown traps. The feeling of being tracked and harried is often accompanied by an awareness of one’s complicity in the hunt, of being capable of various forms of violence, of knowing just how to do unto others that which is being done unto us. The feeling of colluding in an adversarial relationship is, however, quite natural. Conflict is always to some degree cooperative, and adversarial knowledge always entails two mutually dependent propositions—attack implies defence, hiding implies seeking. The prey necessarily understands the techniques of the hunter, otherwise they could not ever escape.

Thus vulnerability makes hunters of us all, despite our best wishes and our desire to live and let live. We seek each and every opportunity, we try to divine the secret and discern the latent, in the hope that we can acquire even a minimal advantage that might permit us to ride out the onrushing waves of chance and uncertainty that we know will soon catch up with us. We don’t need to exploit every lever that we find in the world, but it seems necessary to be able to find them nonetheless. It is not about being strong or powerful, but about being aware, awake and alert to the way in which the transformation of circumstances might take place. Contingency forces us into a position of internal tension, pressures us to become both hunter and quarry, hound and fox.

So if complicity, duality and opposition are our lot today, what can we gain from this situation, beyond our own moral compromise? The techniques of the prey are useful, to be sure, but they are known to us all. We are born at a disadvantage, and only slowly do we acquire more potent abilities. Some, through their privilege, forget what it is to hide and survive, but most do not have this luxury. But if not the techniques of escape and evasion, what about those of seeking, tracking, or trapping? What can we we learn from the knowledge of the hunter?

It would be nice to say, ‘nothing’, for hunting is brutal even when it is necessary and cruel when it is not, yet it is obviously significant if only because hunting behaviours are present in all forms, scales and environments of life. From microorganisms to social bodies, the forms and codes of hunting appear and reappear across landscapes, species and media, and their functions represent critical links between the systems of ecology, the drives of biology and the designs of technology. Even the basic forms of pursuit and capture implied by hunting are significant as diagrams for modern relations of power—as in the predator’s prediction of the prey’s line of flight, and its simulated interception at an imagined point in the future. However, if we wish to go beyond these metaphors of domination and capture, to find the means by which such relationships can not only be reversed but inverted, we can find an even more subtle model of survival in the technological lifeworld by examining the complex weaving of time, technics, knowledge and violence that is implied in the creation and use of traps.

In the art of creating and using traps we find a field of action exemplary of the form of intelligence commonly known as cunning, a mental disposition shared by snare hunters with tricksters, sophists, generals and con artists, and indeed with all beings who make use of hidden signs and advantages. Cunning is the art of twists and turns, a combined ability to detect, exploit and reverse the hidden relations of power and meaning latent in an environment—all to one’s advantage, of course. The layer of traps manipulates the forms and signs of life and world, combining hard truths with subtle illusions through the skill of their minds and hands. To hunt with traps is quite different from the overt power of hunting with speed and force, the hunting of chasing and running down to strike and destroy. The trap implies a very different kind of knowledge, a different domain of technique and ability.

First, to construct a trap requires deep and detailed knowledge of the form-of-life to be trapped—its habits, needs, desires, potentials—and then for this knowledge to be realised through the construction of a technical system, using only certain materials inherent and native to a particular landscape. This knowledge concerns both being and signs, a combination of sensitive observations and an intuition that comes only with years of experience.

Second, the trap maker needs to understand the environment, the ecology, the interrelation of life and growth that situates both themselves and their target. Like the pursuit hunter, the trapper needs to read the weather signs, the trails and paths, the signs of other beings, to infer from all of these the right steps to take and materials to select. But unlike the tracker who uses their knowledge to create the linear form of the chase, the layer of traps takes this knowledge and enfolds it, knots it, weaves it into more subtle forms, trusting in their skill and mind to produce effects distributed across time and space.

And thirdly, not only is a trap a model of the target, but it is also a diagram of the maker, demonstrating their knowledge, their skill, and their sensitivity to the world around them. The form of a trap, the efficacy of its sensors, triggers and restraints, the cleverness of its functioning and the obscurity of its concealment, all these can be read as a model of the mind of the maker. Like all skills rooted in artifice, in the combination of detecting and deceiving, concealing and inventing, a trap is the material embodiment of an ecological form of knowledge, the knowledge of a system whose circuit continually feeds back between other- environment-self, insisting on their continuity, and allowing no false separation between them.

As a device that models the mind of its target, that embodied the intentions of its maker, and that instrumentalises the signs of the environment, the trap can be seen as more than a tool or technique, it is a complex function of the mind, a set of relations between self, other and world, a relation that can be transposed into almost any medium. From ties that bind to software that ensnares, from technologies of entrapment to the illusions of media, the topology of the trap appears to be present in the very heart of our technical civilisation, a model for the instruments and systems out of which we have constructed our artificial lifeworld, a metaphor for the state in which we find ourselves today: trapped in a complex socio-technical relationship whose nature we have only understood too late. A trap is a story, a beautiful illusion, a subtle device whose action may be both dangerous and liberating.

But despite all of these points regarding the epistemic and semiotic sources of interest and mystery that lie embedded in traps, when we return from abstraction to reality it is hard to see the trap as anything but a cruel and vicious exercise in power and violence. Is it possible, somehow, to imagine a benevolent trap? A loving trap? What would it mean to be cunning without cruelty?

Once again, the trap has something to tell us about the nature of capture. The most perfect example of a trap is not a hidden pit or a woven snare, but a circumstance subjected to a reversal of fortune, accomplished through the discovery of hidden sources of possibility, found just where no one thought to look. A trap is a form of technics that serves to demonstrate that no situation is permanent and universal, that anything can be transformed into it’s opposite, including techniques whose primary application are deception, suspicion or violence. It is up to us today, those of us who feel trapped, not to ignore, forget or disavow the techniques of the hunter, nor to cynically bow to them. It is up to us to transform traps, to take their topology, their system of relations, and transform them into tools not of capture but of embeddedness, new ways of tying us into the world more securely, weaving us into the structures of life and community such that we can never be forcibly untangled by those who hunt us and capture us, hoping to use us for our life energy.

Loving traps are those situations that have been designed to implicate all participants in their operations, and instead of the hidden construction of a determinate future, employ the latent creation of a system open to infinite continuity.

If our world is such that we cannot escape complicity in systems of conflict and capture, then we must turn our careful and sensitive attention to their nature and functioning. We must become experts in traps, not only to avoid stepping into them wherever possible, but to dismantle, disassemble, subvert and redeploy them for better purposes. Traps to encourage community, traps to create complicity in creation, traps to entangle us in each others’ lives to such a degree that we cannot see ourselves as separate, isolated, unaddressed. The art of the living trap takes what is native to the ecological being—sensitivity to hidden signs, action through opportunity—and, like all traps and tricks and ingenious devices, reverses expectations, upends relations of power and meaning, and transforms the world into a system of conscious, intentional and mutual complicity.

(This essay was written as a catalogue text to accompany the exhibition Social Attraction, presented by the artist Scott Rogers at the Third Kamias Triennial, February 7-22, 2020, Quezon City, Metro Manila, Philippines. The exhibit consisted of hand painted polyurethane Chinese Crested Tern decoys, which are used to deceive endangered birds into returning to previously abandoned nesting sites. After the triennial the decoys will be redistributed for use in further Chinese Crested Tern conservation.)

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s